Interview · Choosing a trainer
Choosing a Weight Loss Personal Trainer in Calgary
Don't choose a trainer on looks, Paul Anthony says. Ask how much experience they have, ask to see real before-and-after transformations, and ask whether you can talk to a client. Then see how their process starts.
The conversation
Key insights
- 01
Ask how much experience a trainer has; don't hire on looks alone.
- 02
Ask to see before-and-after transformations from real clients.
- 03
Ask whether you can speak with a current or past client.
- 04
A good process starts with a consultation and assessment, not a sales pitch.
01
Don't hire on looks
Paul Anthony has been coaching for more than 30 years, and he has watched the fitness industry change. His first piece of advice for anyone hiring a weight loss personal trainer in Calgary is not to judge by appearance.
“There are a lot of new trainers in the fitness industry now who are 18, 19, 20 years old, and they get hired because they look good.”
Paul Anthony
Looking fit and knowing how to coach a 45-year-old through fat loss are different skills. Here are the questions Paul suggests asking instead.
02
Question 1: how much experience do you have?
Ask how long they have been coaching and who they usually work with. If your goal is weight loss after 40, ask how often they work with clients like you.
03
Question 2: can I see your results?
“Ask for some before-and-after transformations, or whether you could call a client, whatever it is. You've got to have some proof.”
Paul Anthony
Real transformations, shared with clients' permission, show what a trainer has actually achieved. Testimonials help; a conversation with a real client helps more.
04
Question 3: can I talk to one of your clients?
Paul calls this social proof and physical proof. A trainer with a track record should be comfortable connecting you with someone who has been through the program.
“I have over 30 years of experience, so I have lots of social proof and lots of physical proof from clients.”
Paul Anthony
05
Question 4: how does your process start?
Ask what happens in the first weeks. A good answer includes an assessment and a plan that starts where you are. At Dreambody, it works like this:
- Free consultation at the gym or by phone, to talk through your goals and health situation.
- Assessment and interview covering where you are now, where you want to go, your medical history and key measurements.
- Your custom plan: workouts and a meal plan built from your goals and stats.
- Level 1. Everyone starts at the first of Paul's 12 levels and moves up as they execute well. Read how the levels work.
06
Question 5: where does your role stop?
A good trainer knows when something is a medical question. Paul recommends that clients with sudden weight gain, or who are really struggling in the first couple of weeks, see their doctor. That is a sign of a coach who puts your health first.
Ready to ask Paul these questions yourself? Book a free consultation through Calgary personal training or see Calgary weight loss programs.
Check with your doctor first. If you have a medical condition, take medication, are dealing with sudden or unexplained weight gain, or have symptoms that worry you, speak with your physician before starting or changing a program. Paul is a personal trainer, not a medical provider, and this article is general information, not medical advice.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
What should I ask a personal trainer before hiring them?
Paul suggests asking how much experience they have, asking to see before-and-after transformations and asking whether you can speak with a client.
How much experience does Paul Anthony have?
Paul has more than 30 years of experience. He is a world champion natural bodybuilder and has been named Personal Trainer of the Year in Alberta for 12+ years.
How do I start with Dreambody?
Book a free consultation in the gym or by phone. You will talk through your goals and health situation, then complete an assessment before your custom plan is built.
Does Paul train clients outside Calgary?
Yes, through online personal training with custom workouts, a meal plan and video check-ins every couple of weeks.
Read the full transcript
This transcript has been lightly edited for clarity: filler words and repeated questions were removed and obvious speech-to-text errors were corrected. Brief passages marked [...] were omitted, along with closing questions about permissions and scheduling. The client example is anonymized.
Sam (StyleLabs)Let's start with your typical clients over 40. What kinds of goals and concerns do they usually bring to you at Dreambody?
PaulUsually weight loss, body contouring, building some lean muscle mass, and just getting leaner.
Sam (StyleLabs)From your coaching experience, what tends to make fat loss feel harder for people after 40, and what approaches still work well for them?
PaulLike for everyone else: eating healthy, and eating enough protein especially. Women especially don't have enough protein. Protein intake is usually low, about half of what it should be. Most women should have over 100 grams of protein. Let's say they weigh about 130 pounds: they should have about 100 grams of protein. Most have 30 to 50 grams, really, and the rest is mostly carbs and vegetables.
Sam (StyleLabs)When you're working with someone over 40 who is starting strength training for the first time, or coming back after a break, how do you structure their program so it's safe and effective?
PaulI have different levels of training, level 1 to level 12. So if they were at level 5 when they quit, when they come back they go right back to level 1 and start over. It's like an airplane taking off. You start off very low, then the airplane takes off and accelerates into the sky. So you start off at level 1, then level 2, level 3, level 4, and you move up according to where you are.
Sam (StyleLabs)For men over 40, what patterns do you notice with fat loss, recovery and consistency? And how does that compare with what you see in women?
PaulMen usually hold it around the belly, like a beer belly type. That's where they hold most of their fat. Women usually hold it in their lower body: hamstrings, butt, thighs, inner thigh, outer thigh and so on. That's how the fat is normally distributed.
Sam (StyleLabs)For women in perimenopause or menopause, what do they usually tell you they're struggling with, and how do you adapt their training and help set realistic expectations?
PaulWomen in their 40s going through perimenopause, usually it's weight loss and sudden weight gain. What I tell people going through menopause is that they need to do a little bit more higher-intensity cardio. For example, sprints of 30 seconds at a time, then a two- or three-minute break, is really good. [...] So more interval-type training is good for menopause and perimenopause. But first I start them off a little lighter. And also strength training: you need strength training two to four times a week as well, and an adequate amount of protein. Those are the things that are very important.
Sam (StyleLabs)Where does a trainer's role end? Are there situations where you recommend clients see their physician before or during a program, especially over 40?
PaulFor those over 40 with a lot of sudden weight gain, yes. I also like to see where they're at for probably the first two weeks. Then, if they're really having big-time struggles, I might suggest they see where their hormones are at. If estrogen is out of control, testosterone is very low or their thyroid might be off, I really want to make sure the doctor, ideally an expert in female hormones specifically, checks their hormones.
Sam (StyleLabs)When you coach nutrition and protein, how do you guide clients without crash diets or rigid promises about weight loss?
PaulI try not to get into too much about specifics. I just say: “You need at least three meals a day, with protein, carbs, vegetables and fats, essential fatty acids preferably. That should boost your energy. You need carbs to boost your energy so you can work hard, and protein for sure. So you need all four to boost your energy and sustain it throughout the day.” It also affects their mood. It makes them happy when they have protein.
Sam (StyleLabs)How do sleep, stress and recovery affect your clients' progress, and what do you do as a coach to help them in those areas?
PaulFor sleep, I tell them to sleep seven to nine hours per night, and to make sure they get their sleep in. Some might have disrupted sleep, so I may tell them to have [...] a chamomile or mint tea to calm them down at night. Try not to eat two hours before you go to sleep, so you're able to relax. For energy, make sure you have your protein throughout the day, because protein sustains and satiates the body and mind for energy. So an adequate amount of protein, carbs, vegetables and fats is very, very important for energy.
Sam (StyleLabs)Can you share an anonymized example of a client, with no names or identifying details, that shows your approach?
PaulI have countless examples. I had one client in her 50s who had tried three other trainers, and nothing worked. She was going through menopause, and she was frustrated with me at first, saying, “This won't work. I've tried this. Dieting doesn't work.” Then we started her on the program. She ended up losing close to 40 pounds following the program: high intensity, and balanced protein, carbs and essential fats, just like my regular protocol. We increased the intensity of her workouts and increased her weightlifting as well. She got really lean, and then she said, “You know what? I want to do a competition.” So we did a fitness competition, and she won it. She went from high body fat, weight gain, not being able to sleep and feeling moody to just feeling good, with everyone in the gym commenting on how good she was looking. She got first place. So that's one of my examples.
Sam (StyleLabs)If someone in Calgary is thinking about hiring a personal trainer for weight loss, what should they ask before choosing, and what does your process look like when someone first starts with you at Dreambody?
PaulI'd suggest asking the trainer or coach how much experience they have, because there are a lot of new trainers in the fitness industry now who are 18, 19, 20 years old, and they get hired because they look good. They look good because they're young and they've been working out. [...] So instead of just going on looks, ask about experience, and ask for some before-and-after transformations, or whether you could call a client, whatever it is. You've got to have some proof: some social proof and some physical proof of their work. I have over 30 years of experience, so I have lots of social proof and lots of physical proof from clients.
Sam (StyleLabs)Is there anything else that's important to your business that we haven't covered?
PaulMostly that my program has 12 different levels. Everyone starts at level one, the basic level, even if they think they're an expert. Sometimes people think they're an expert, but they really are not. So I start everyone at level one, and from there we graduate either every two weeks, every month or every two months. Some people need longer in level one, two months, some even three months. We'll see. They graduate according to how they're actually executing in their workouts, and their dieting, cardio and so on. I move them up to a different level depending on their proficiency in the workouts.
More from this interview